The term “systemic racism” has come
to prominence these last few years, as the crowning expression of “woke”
ideology. The term, and the concepts it
represents are doomed to fail in the quest to right the wrongs of America's
past, because they are a complete misdiagnosis of the basic problem. In addition to being racist in its own right,
it has the flaw that since it tries to cover so many things it becomes a
meaningless mush; a sweeping indictment of everything everywhere. As such, it ends up covering nothing. One
begins to suspect it is desperate, if not cynical, attempt to make sense of a
long and painful unsolved mystery.
Hence, it has devolved into little more than another of humanity's
consensual paranoid delusions, totally incapable of healing the pain and
frustration it pretends to offer as a cure.
The pain and frustration seem to
come from not just the years of
widespread and legal African American oppression, but more especially
from the time since the civil rights movement.
Since that time no official racism has been allowed, and yet the African
American community has not only not made great progress, but has in many ways
regressed. Certainly, family breakdown, drug use, crime and violence have
increased in the black community since the 1960’s. What’s more, with the immigration of various
African ethnic communities, and their subsequent rise in American culture, the
comparison with the seemingly perpetual social malaise in the wider African
American community has caused increasing frustration.
It seems to many people as if
something has been done, and continues to be done, to African Americans that is
keeping them down. No one can exactly
define what is being done, but there is widespread sentiment that something bad
was and is being done, and somehow White people are responsible for it. Thus, the delusional concept of systemic
racism to gain acceptance. The strategy
that has emerged from this concept is to try to chase down and exterminate said
invisible bogeyman of systemic racism. The
tactic then becomes to confront and abuse random White people until they admit
their hitherto unknown racism, and reinforce the credibility of the
questionable concept. So the idea, and the tactics continue, with still no
progress being made.
That strategy is doomed to failure
because it is based on an inaccurate diagnosis of the problem. Yes, many of the ongoing, multi generational
problems in the African American community are the result of what White people
did to Black people, but the abuse has almost all ended while the problems
persist. To end the problems and repair
the damage (the real meaning of reparations) we must first accurately diagnose
the problem. Once we do that, we will
see that naming the remedy is relatively easy.
Stating the diagnosis is the
simple, albeit probably painful part much like ripping the dressing off an old
wound. Simply put, the great wound
inflicted on African Americans is two-fold.
First, the mode of their importation and enslavement rendered them into
what is essentially a new ethnic group.
Second, this new ethnic group, which was inadvertently formed as a side
effect of the efficient yet inhumane machinery of mass enslavement, has, since
its genesis, been deprived of the blessings and burdens of community self-determination. These two aspects, which will be detailed
shortly, have combined to induce a debilitating and continuing impairment in
African American culture.
Let’s unpack the first aspect which
is that African Americans were rendered into a new ethnic group at their birth.
Consider the unprecedented depth of the cultural dismantling that took place
during the great African enslavement in the United States. Each individual African was stripped of
almost all cultural accouterments and the psychological identity that came with
them. First, their clothes were taken
and when they landed in the new world they were forced to accept European
clothes. Their language was brutally
suppressed, along with any cultural forms or tribal associations. Any
communication with family or friends back in Africa was totally
impossible. Since the number of slaves
was relatively large compared to the number of Whites, fear of a slave uprising
motivated the White slave owners to be intensely diligent in obliterating any
expression of Black identity, unity, or self determination.
When, after enduring all this
psychological trauma, the individual African American returned to social
cohesion, it was in stilted English and as a member of the most abused and
demeaned group in the new nation, permanently on the bottom of the social
ladder. A new people, conceived in enslaved suffering and formed by the powers
of greed and fear, were born anew on God’s earth. They carried forward
virtually no shared memories of a previous existence, and there were no ethnic
distinctions between the various enslaved African peoples that were recognized
or meaningful.
This
experience is unique, certainly in America, and probably, given the size of the
enslavement and the depth of the cultural dismantling, in the world. Even the far greater number of African slaves
brought to Latin America didn’t suffer anything like that total cultural
dismantling. They were arguably treated
more brutally, often being worked to death, but they were left to speak and
associate as they wished. The other ethnic groups that came to America, or that
were already here, didn’t suffer any where near this degree of cultural
obliteration.
The Native Americans, although
decimated on a large scale, were cheated and lied to but still retained their
tribal councils and a degree of national self determination. Happily, almost all of their cultural
institutions are witnessing revival today. By way of comparison with enslaved
African Americans, the Irish, the Chinese, and the Mexicans, who were probably
the most ill treated of the various immigrant ethnic groups, still kept their
clothes, their foods, their languages, and were still able to keep in touch
with their families in the old country.
Even in the face of some opposition, they were allowed to associate with
each other as they chose. They
congregated in their own neighborhoods and in their own towns. After two or three generations they would
start to move out into the larger culture, confidently moving forward from a
position of strength because they had a political and economic power base since
they been allowed to exercise a great degree of community self-determination.
This brings up the second aspect of
the wound that has been inflicted on African Americans, which is that this new
ethnic group, unlike any other group in human history, has never exercised
meaningful community self-determination.
There is a consciousness that grows naturally in any group that has any
degree of self-determination, and has developed since ancient times in every
group in the world. Even in a country as
repressed as ancient China, the local warlord demanded tribute, but he left
most problems, such as water, food, medical care, moral restraint, the
consequences of immorality, and almost all the other cultural issues, to be
worked out by the local villagers. The
same was true in Ireland, where the English rulers took the wheat as rent, and
left the Irish to fend for themselves on rotting potatoes. The same dynamic held true for immigrants
from Latin America and the other areas of Europe and Asia.
When these
villagers from the various areas in the world arrived in America, they had a
history and a memory of how to run their own communities. Even if they weren’t from the exact same
villages, members of these ethnic groups shared the same or similar language,
systems of taboos, personal responsibilities and expectations. What’s more, they knew without even thinking
about it how to pass these on to their children.
In fact,
the same thing was and is true throughout Africa. The Africans who were forced on to the slave
boats would, if they had been left to their own devices, have been more than
capable of forming together in healthy, self governing communities, and would
have achieved a strong power base just like every other group has. A quick look at the modern experience of the
Ethiopian, Somali, Nigerian, and other African immigrant communities confirms
this truth.
But African
Americans back then weren’t left to their own devices. They were enslaved and their culture
destroyed. Since they were someone
else's property, their well being, in terms of drinkable water, medical care,
food, and shelter, was under the responsibility and authority of their White
owners. We can thank God that since
racism was so extreme, Blacks were left to study the Bible and live the Gospel
of Jesus Christ on their own. However,
even in the area of sexual morality, Blacks were encouraged to be promiscuous,
as it enabled slave owners to more easily sell family members for monetary
gain, and to engage in selective breeding.
The point is that African Americans
weren’t allowed to exercise the powers of self government, of
self-determination, and therefore weren’t forced to respond to the challenges
of self-government. They were to know their place, do their jobs, and any
community problems that arose were to be dealt with by the master in the big
house. Usually, the leader of the local
Black community was selected by the owner and was the one who might
successfully persuade the master to meet some of the community’s needs.
Things
really didn’t change much after slavery.
There were many in the African American community who recognized the
opportunities and responsibilities inherent in freedom, and worked with courage
and enthusiasm to meet them. However,
even during Reconstruction, and certainly afterward in the era of Jim Crow,
their efforts were thwarted with brutal oppression and terrorism.
Well into
the 20th Century, African Americans were kept in near slavery, with
no seat at the table where decisions are made.
The worst aspect of this, far worse than the simple lack of
self-determination, was the fact that the conditions that develop a healthy
consciousness of self-government were still absent. It must be acknowledged that there were some
exceptions to this, like Mound Bayou, Mississippi and some few towns run by
African Americans in Oklahoma and elsewhere, but they were too few to change
the larger African American culture.
Even without most of the powers of
self government African America continued to rise. A business class arose, when it wasn’t being
bombed out as in Greenburg, Oklahoma.
The Black families were becoming stronger and more stable all the way
through the 1950’s. With the success of
the Civil Rights Movement, African Americans demonstrated that they had
achieved enough strength and influence to gain political equality with
Whites. Then the third crime perpetrated
against African America. after slavery and Jim Crow, was the Great Society of
Lyndon Johnson.
Close on
the heels of the equalizing Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts (1964-65),
Lyndon Johnson enacted a series of socialist programs, called the Great
Society. While seeming to have good
intentions these programs continued the crime against the African American
community because they once again denied to Blacks the powers and burdens of
self determination. There are some who
might say that there is poetic justice in this because self-determination was
also largely taken from the White community at the same time, but that should
be small solace because the tragic wounding of the Black community continued
unabated.
Consider
how many cultural decisions used to be made (by Whites) at the local level, and
are now made at the federal level. Health
care, public relief, moral education of the young, control of pornography, and
many other issues, ranging from how to provide clean water and sanitation to
how to generate local jobs used to be made by local communities. From 1933 to 1963, a nascent socialism (a
topic for another day) took root and fully bloomed in the late 1960’s, removing
almost all the powers and burdens of moral self government from all the people,
even the white people, just shortly after African Americans gained a real
measure of political equality. Truly,
the pie turned rotten just as they finally got a piece of it.
Truly, the pie turned rotten just as they finally got
a piece of it.
Look at the
similar cultural effects of these three conditions. In slavery, there was an alienation from the
legal structure. The master made the
rules, and if one could get away with breaking them, very few of the fellow
slaves would hold them to account. As
long as what was being done didn’t threaten to bring down the master’s wrath,
it was of no concern to the community because the community hadn’t made the
rules. That same thinking held true
during Jim Crow. The “man” made the
rules, so if you could get away with skirting them, more power to you. That thinking was slowly losing ground until
the 1960’s, but it has come back with a vengeance since then.
“The Man”
is back, and these days Whites, and everybody else, are in the same boat. Look at how we all think today. “We” don’t talk about what “we” are going to
do to solve a problem. “They” have to
solve the problem, and “they” are expected to provide us with all our
wants.
We are to
do our jobs and get away with what we can.
Whether it’s cheating the welfare system, cheating on our taxes, or
cheating in traffic, it’s only wrong if you get caught because we have no
social obligation to each other. If
there is any problem, “they” have to solve it.
Our leaders are those who can get the master…er the man… er, I mean the
federal government, to come up with the money to solve our problems for
us. This really is the mindset of almost
the entire country and some of our leading thinkers are correct in calling this
a plantation mentality.
So, what is the solution? How do we
go about healing this almost 400-year-old wound in the African American
community? The great wounding of African
America will end and the healing begin when African Americans are free and
equal citizens of self-governing communities.
That can only happen when most of the powers of self government are
devolved from the federal government and revert back into the hands of state
and local governments.
The great wounding of African America will end and the
healing begin when African Americans are free and equal citizens of
self-governing communities.
“Hold on there,” one can hear the
roar of protest. “Isn’t this just advocating a return to states rights?” Yes and no, mostly no. First of all, only people have rights, and
according to Jefferson, we delegate certain powers to government to secure
those rights. This is merely saying we
should delegate far fewer powers to the federal government and return them to
the states and localities.
“States rights” as advocated by
those who called for them, were always about the states being able to deny
rights that had already been established, and it was therefore a total
lie. Both the states and the federal
government dropped the ball and didn’t honestly enforce the 13th, 14th
and 15th Amendments for nearly 100 years. This situation has been used in the last 60
years since the Civil Right Acts to completely discredit local self-government,
but that is a misreading of history because the federal government was
complicit and contributed to Jim Crow just as much as the states. Here, at this point of seeing the
equivocation of the federal courts and how they cynically did not use an
originalist, strict construction of the Constitution, especially when ruling on
the post Civil War amendments, is where one might find the invisible bogeyman
ghost of systemic racism. However, it
won’t be found by attacking the innocent or even well meaning words of some
random White folks in the 2020’s.
So if the
cure is to establish true self-determination for the African American
community, the struggle promises to be difficult because some powerful forces
want to deny self-determination to all Americans, and to all humans for that
matter. There might be some ready allies
in the (conservative) White community who are concerned about the same issues
if the two groups can find their way to each other. Perhaps a revival of the efforts at
reconciliation can be ignited within the (mostly conservative) Christian
community. Such an effort promises to bear beautiful fruit. Further, by all means, the voices in the
African American community calling for moral revival, self initiative, economic
self sufficiency, and all the other civic and personal virtues should be
welcomed and amplified because of such ideals are all healthy communities
built.
Nonetheless, the burden of self
determination must be sought and borne if the great wound is to be healed. Some might complain that absorbing all the
changes this path entails is not fair.
Why must the victims endure even more pain? Such objections are valid, because this is
not fair, just as it’s not fair that the victim of a brutal assault must
generate the self discipline and endure the pain of rehabilitation in order to
recover from the assault. Sure, the
assault victim and the victims of racism and slavery could just blame the
perpetrators (White people in this case) for their problems, and remain
wounded. Or they could demand, and maybe
even receive some financial reparations, a court settlement from the criminals,
feel good for a while, but if they continue to dodge the pain of rehabilitation
they will remain wounded.
Or they could, like a victim
choosing painful rehabilitation, find their own healing. (Here the analogy
slightly breaks down, because the African American community would be gaining
something they were deprived of since their genesis, not regaining something
they previously had.) In the courageous
spirit of their forebears, they can seek the finish line of community
self-determination, meet the difficult challenges of moral self-government when
it is gained, and thereby begin to heal the centuries old wound. Such a strategy, while it will be
challenging, is the only way to heal and is guaranteed to bear much sweeter and
much more abundant fruit than the angry quest to root out the mythical bogeyman
of “systemic racism” ever can.